Need recommendations for truly terrifying horror games that will scare me

I want to find a horror game that will actually make me jump and feel scared while playing. I’ve already played games like Outlast and Alien Isolation which were pretty good at creating that scary atmosphere I’m looking for.

The problem is that many games labeled as horror on Steam don’t seem designed to actually frighten players. Take Resident Evil 4 for example - sure it has zombies and creatures but the main character feels too powerful with all his weapons and combat moves. That doesn’t create the helpless scary feeling I want.

I’ve been considering Fear and Hunger because people say it’s really dark and disturbing. The type of game that stays with you even after you stop playing. My only concern is that it uses turn-based combat which might break the tension.

What horror games would you recommend that focus on creating genuine fear and suspense? I want something that will make me hesitate to play alone at night and actually give me goosebumps.

Try playing Silent Hill 2. It has a haunting atmosphere that sticks with you.

Playing Phasmophobia with friends is terrifying. The ghost AI doesn’t care that you’re in a group - it’ll still scare the hell out of you.

Visage is absolutely brutal if you can handle the slow burn. It’s like PT but way more disturbing and actually finished.

SOMA’s exactly what you want. No jump scares - just this slow-building existential horror that gets under your skin. You’re helpless most of the time, and the story will mess with your head for days after. Amazing atmosphere, though I’ll admit there were moments I wasn’t sure I wanted to keep going when things got really dark.

Madison will mess you up. It’s pure psychological terror and that camera mechanic is nightmare fuel.